Imagine a world where men don’t exist, and women live in perfect harmony. Sounds like a page ripped right out of Herland. While some women may bemoan nature’s way of making men necessary for our species’ continued survival, a male-free existence isn’t always science fiction. Evolution has found a way to make males obsolete in one species of lizards.
Whiptail lizards are found in the deserts of New Mexico and Arizona. There is one species, Aspidoscelis uniparens or the Desert Grassland Whiptail that has been well studied for its ability to reproduce through parthenogenesis, where females use asexual reproduction to produce offspring without male fertilization. They’re also studied because despite having no males, females will still engage in both male and female sexual behaviors with each other.
Fig. 1: Desert grassland whiptail lizards are all born female and can only reproduce via parthenogenesis. (Source: Brent Myers)
Why would all-female asexual lizards bother getting it on if fertilization is pointless? Well, to understand their behavior, you first must understand the point of sexual reproduction.
Sexual reproduction is when male gametes (sperm) fuse with female gametes (eggs) to bring DNA together and form a new, unique individual. The main advantage of sexual reproduction over asexual reproduction is the creation of genetic diversity into a new organism. If you are simply a clone of your parent, genetically, your chances at responding to changes in the environment aren’t any better than your progenitor. But sexual reproduction allows for an entirely new combination of genetic materials to come together, and no two siblings are going to be exactly the same.
In parthenogenesis, the female eggs will become clones of the female. A. uniparens is an exception, where they produce genetically distinct offspring by starting with twice the DNA and shuffle their own genetic makeup . Typically, when eggs and sperm are made, they each double their DNA and then go through two divisions so they only contain half of the genetic makeup (haploid) in each cell (Fig 2). Then when a sperm fertilizes an egg, the chromosomes come together to form a unique individual cell. For A. uniparens, the egg cells remain diploid (both sets of chromosomes) when splitting because of the initial doubling of DNA occurs twice. During these doubling events, genetic recombination occurs by patches of DNA being cut from one chromatid and repaired on the sister. This results in unique individuals for A. uniparens.
Fig. 2: Normal process of meiosis where DNA doubles once followed by two divisions so that one cell becomes four with haploid DNA. Color changes illustrates crossover of DNA. For A. uniparens, doubling happens twice just before meiosis begins so that daughter cells end as diploid. Source: Rdbickel.
Sexual reproduction is the primary mode of producing offspring amongst vertebrates such as birds, mammals, and reptiles like whiptail species. While there are many variations in how animals have sex, evolution has provided a hormonal system that is fairly consistent across sexually reproducing animals.
Ovaries contain eggs. They also release the sex hormones estradiol (an estrogen) and progesterone at different times during a female’s cycle to prime eggs for fertilization and create a nice habitat for developing embryos. Before ovulation, estradiol increases in the body, signaling to the ovary to release its most mature egg for fertilization. High estradiol also communicates to the brain that it should increase desire in females to be more receptive towards male intercourse. After ovulation, estradiol drops dramatically and the hormone progesterone increases. Sexual receptivity also declines in females with high progesterone and they ready their bodies for growing the potential new life.
This hormonal process occurs in sexual species of whiptail lizards. Males mount females when estradiol is high, and females become unreceptive when estradiol is low. However, for A. uniparens there are no males to speak of. Instead, females use their already efficient hormonal system to switch roles. When parthenogenetic lizards have high estradiol, just like their sexual counterparts, they become receptive to mounting by other females. For female lizards who have low estradiol and high progesterone, they instead produce “male-like” behavior and mount high estradiol receptive females . It’s a sort of “you scratch my back, I’ll scratch yours” exchange.
Fig. 3: Hormone levels change during the female reproductive cycle of A. uniparens. Female receptive behavior occurs during high estradiol levels during ovulation (blue line). Mounting other females occurs during high progesterone levels (red line). Source: Amanda Krentzel.
So how does the brain control this versatile switching? Researchers find that in the preoptic area (POA) of the hypothalamus of the asexual lizards, high estradiol increases the receptor for progesterone, making the brain ready to receive progesterone’s signal. This increase in progesterone receptor is not seen in females of the sexual species, indicating that this is a specific adaptation for A. uniparens, and likely why sexually reproducing females aren’t mounting other lizards during progesterone surges [3,4]. Instead, in the sexual species, the POA is rich in the receptor for testosterone in males, which is the hormone that usually drives mounting in males across the animal kingdom. Since A. uniparens are male-free and testosterone light, they use this system to produce mounting behavior, with progesterone taking over what testosterone used to do.
For most sexual species, male-like mounting and female-like receptivity are usually organized early in embryonic development of the brain and cannot be switched by adult hormones later in life. However, A. uniparens defies this convention, demonstrating the flexibility of the female brain to adapt to a male-free world.
Now, whether the all-female whiptails are living in a utopia is up for interpretation.
 Lutes, Aracely A.,William B. Neaves, Diana P. Baumann, W. Wiegraebe, and Peter Baumann “Sister chromosome pairing maintains heterozygosity in parthenogenetic lizards.” Nature 464 (2010): 283-86.
 Moore, MC, JM Whittier, D Crews. “Sex steroid hormones during the ovarian cycle of an all-female parthenogenetic lizard and their correlation with pseudosexual behavior”. Gen Com Endocrinol. 60 (1985): 144-53.
 Rhen, T. and Crews, D. “Why are there two sexes?” * Sex Differences of the Brain: From Genes to Behavior*. (New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2008). 3-14.
 Wooley, S.C., J.T. Sakata, and D. Crews. “Tracing the Evolution of Brain and Behavior Using Two Related Species of Whiptail Lizards: Cnemidophorus uniparens and Cnemidophorus inornatus.” ILAR J. 45 (2004): 46-53.
More From Thats Life [Science]
- Eavesdropping in the Animal Kingdom: Sneaky Creatures Just Trying to Get Ahead
- Trypanosomes - A Weird Pathogen You Haven't Heard Of
- A Beautiful 9/11 Tribute, but a Fiasco for Migratory Birds
- Cats can have AIDS, too.
- Part 2: Does catching Pidgeys help you notice Pigeons? Interviews with Pokémon Go Researchers
- Biodiversity in my Backyard: Encounters with Pidgeys and Dratinis, Part 1
- Fins, Limbs, Rays, and Digits – A Beginner's Guide to Terrestrial Living
- Five things that really stink about the Brown Marmorated Stink Bug
- Tricks but no Treats - An Orchid’s Guide to Making a Fool of Your Pollinator
- Tracking the lost years - where do baby sea turtles grow?
- Posing as a Bird Mama: the adventures of a researcher-turned-bird-parent
- Hot moves and sexy sons · When Boys Become Men By Dancing
- The hungry caterpillar in real life
- Mantis Shrimp Vision - Seeing in Secret Code
- When It Comes to Bird Beaks - Size Matters
- Is your gut trying to kill your resolve? · Mind over microbe
- Recent talk of walls in the media has brought up a lot of emotions, but what do walls do in nature? · When a Wall is just a Wall
- Bees are more than buzzing insects around you · May the Bees Be With You: Maintaining the Sweet Balance in Life
- Neither a toad nor a worm · Nematodes: The super microscopic animal!
- Snap! Flash! Bang! Find out how ocean-dwelling pistol shrimp fire bubble ‘bullets’ to stun their unsuspecting prey. · How Pistol Shrimp Kill with Bubbles
- Who needs males after all?
- Ecology and Behavior of Woodchucks · Opposition Research on My Garden’s Greatest Nemesis
- Vision in Jumping Spiders · Watching Your Every Move
- Slimed and Consumed - The Blob is Real!
- The Evolution and Ecological Impacts of Cats · Lion in Sheep's Clothing
- What happens when frogs have to compete for acoustic space and a chance to be heard? · Struggling to be Heard - Competition in a Complex Soundscape
- Think Genghis Khan and Napoleon were the most successful invaders? Think again. · Invasive Species and Invasion: Part 1
- When, and how, terror birds invade
- 8 Reasons Plants Are Amazing
- Too Clean for Comfort · How our obsession with cleanliness might be hurting our health
- Stop, evaluate, and listen - serotonin surges when a female is present
- No Teeth, Long Tongue, No Problem - Adaptations for Ant-eating
- The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly - Predators, Parasitoids, and Parasites
- How our microbiome affects our health and vice versa · If you don't care for your microbiome, you might want to start
- Finding new ways to grow bacteria to progress science · Culturing the Least Cultured Members of Society
- Hit the Road Jack
- What Happened to Your Nose?
- Building better plants - Norman Borlaug and the Green Revolution
- Love Songs for Nobody - Birdsong in Winter
- We know we get infections from time to time. Why does this happen? · The Evolution of Virulence
- How cheese rinds may be a valuable tool for microbial discovery · The Unseen World – On Cheese?
- Find Me Where the Wild Things Are
- A commentary on how to make science more ‘clickable’ · You won’t believe this simple trick to tell if your coral is healthy or not
- Some species hide in plain sight, but scientists have ways to suss them out · Cryptic Species Hide in Plain Sight
- Minuscule Hitchhikers Pinch a Ride · Creature Feature - Pseudoscorpions
- World Fish Migration Day 2016!
- Walking With Giant Anteaters
- Why we should care about sea turtles · When A Sea Turtle Balanced Earth
- More ›